alton_lust (alton_lust) wrote,

Whale Wars

I watched a little of this new Animal Planet show called Whale Wars. The animal rights people were chasing a Japanese boat that was killing whales and they yelled over, "You're breaking international law!"
Hmm. Are they? I decided to look it up. The short answer is: No.
The longer, but still summing up, is: There's a group tied into the U.N. that decided back in the mid-80s to hold a moratorium on killing whales until they could figure out what the heck was going on with the whales. What is a sustainable number? How far off from that are we? Where are the whales? What else is effecting them? Are we contributing to it? Those kinds of things. Getting some of these answers unfortunately requires killing whales to gather the data. (Technology limit.) As soon as the moratorium was declared Japan (and others) immediately applied to the big group for permits so they could kill whales for 'scientific purposes'.
Now here's the thing. The group can make recommendations BUT it is up to each individual country whether they will give these permits to /themselves/. Got that? They are required to give an outline of the goals of their research and to share the results within one year of killing the whales - but other than that nobody can say boo. Japan has told itself that it must make full use of any whale it kills for scientific purposes (but it wasn't mentioned what that entails).
All the other countries in the group have told Japan to stop the killing and to find no-lethal means of their collecting data. However they also acknowledge that they have learned a lot from Japan's research.
The biggest point of contention is that Japan is killing whales in an area everyone has agreed is a sanctuary. So /technically/ if no one can kill whales there there's no need to research the conditions of the animals there. The population will never be hunted. (You know, except for science...)
Japan is not breaking the law, but they are doing an end run around it.
Ta Da!

cite! Law of the Sea. UN. NOAA.

  • Down in the boondocks

    Sitting here, la la, waiting for my Ya Ya... With self portrait Pics Actually today I am sitting here in my car sweating…

  • Why hello there

    Terrific. Work is closed indefinately and benefits shall stop end of the month. I've no idea what this means yet. I suppose I shall freak out later…

  • Getting them off my device!

    The graces dancing tree Then I saw it. She's another Ent. I know I posted this stuff before. Yonks ago. Mysterious crop circles appear... Yellow…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.