I kinda fear re-watching it in case it doesn't hold up.
Shout out to my seasonal favorites:
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (I'm a Watcher)
She-Wolf of London
Dark Shadows (which did you prefer?)
Special mention to The Walking Dead for at least the first 4 seasons.
Do you like Supernatural? Charmed (1 or 2)? Sabrina the Teenage Witch? Witches of Waverly Place? American Horror Story? Evil? Lucifer?